What makes a fight?
Years ago, my Sensei dropped a bit of wisdom when he said, “It takes two people to fight. “ He was illustrating a central concept of jujutsu, the ju in the word referring to yielding or giving way. If someone wants to fight you, and you respond to the terms they’ve laid out, there is a fight, and it’s on the aggressor’s terms. If by contrast, the aggressor incites conflict and you circumvent it, there is no fight.
I can hear you thinking Well, that’s not quite true, and I can hear myself thinking the same thing even as I type it…bear with me. This is a somewhat abstract concept. If someone attacks you, and you employ a soft redirecting technique that puts their face into a curb, most people would call that a fight, and call you the victor. On a physical level though, you’ve minimized the conflict by thwarting the attacker’s intended violence. In this hypothetical scenario, you didn’t play their game, you did something different.
Let’s take a typical bar fight. In my experience, these situations arise from a perceived slight rubbing someone’s ego the wrong way. Once one party decides to take (or feign) umbrage, the other party can either deescalate or escalate the situation. Hormones and alcohol being what they are, things usually escalate if only for a bit before someone intervenes. It’s like the analogy of an immovable object and an unstoppable force. Lots of banging around, pretty ugly, not very productive.
Now, I’ve used the above scenario because it’s a cliche we can all imagine easily enough. In real life though, these situations can arise anywhere. Some of the worst fights arise from an unexpected conflict, where neither party wants to back down. I knew one guy who nearly got into a gunfight over road rage. Seriously. Now, think about how many opportunities there were for both guys involved to simply back down before things got too serious. The sight of a gun on the other guy’s hip brought both their senses in this case, but that is not always the case.
In terms of actual physical conflict, “not fighting” yields practical results. By focusing on deescalating the conflict as quickly as possible, you avoid fighting the other guy’s fight. You don’t play his game. Depending on the environment, you may take any action from walking away to rendering them unconscious. ( It should go without saying that this is dictated by sound judgment and observing the law…don’t paralyze someone for calling you names.)
Over the years, I’ve found that simple advice from my Sensei keeps coming back, imparting a little more wisdom each time. I’ve gotten out of some sticky situations, avoided some others, and physically dominated fighters with the same strategy; I didn’t fight their fight.